Experienced Licensed Insurance Sales Producer

Job Description

TOP PRODUCERS WANTED. BRING YOUR EXPERIENCE. ELEVATE YOUR INCOME.

$70,000–$100,000 Annual Earning Opportunity | Base Salary + Commission + Performance Bonuses

Are you an experienced insurance sales professional who consistently meets or exceeds your production goals? Are you confident prospecting, building relationships, overcoming objections, and closing business?

If you're a proven producer looking for a high-performance agency where your experience is valued, your results matter, and your earning potential grows with your success, we want to talk to you.

At Eigel Agency, we're not simply looking for someone who can sell insurance. We're looking for a driven, competitive, experienced producer who knows how to turn opportunities into policies and build a profitable book of business.

This is a production-focused sales position for professionals who know how to sell and are motivated to win.

JOIN AN AWARD-WINNING FARMERS INSURANCE AGENCY

Established in 2022, Eigel Agency has quickly developed a reputation for excellence, growth, and performance in the San Antonio market.

We're proud to have earned Farmers Insurance Toppers Club recognition three consecutive years, placing our agency among the top 10% of Farmers agencies nationwide, along with additional recognition for our performance in life and business insurance.

Our success is built on high standards, accountability, integrity, and delivering exceptional value to our customers.

WHY TOP PRODUCERS CHOOSE EIGEL AGENCY

Strong Income Opportunity

• Competitive base salary plus commission and performance-based bonus opportunities
• $50,000–$100,000 annual earning opportunity based on performance
• Opportunities to increase earnings through consistent production and multi-line sales
• Recognition and incentive opportunities for exceptional results

More Opportunities to Sell

• Agency-provided leads and prospecting opportunities
• Established agency reputation and Farmers brand recognition
• Access to personal lines, commercial, specialty, and life insurance products
• Opportunities to cross-sell and expand existing customer relationships
• AgencyZoom CRM and sales tools to support efficient prospecting, follow-up, and pipeline management

A Performance-Driven Environment

• A team committed to growth, accountability, and measurable results
• Clear production expectations and defined performance goals
• Proven sales processes, coaching, and ongoing professional development
• Leadership that recognizes initiative, consistency, and results
• Opportunities for advancement based on performance and contribution

OUR PRODUCTION EXPECTATIONS

Successful sales professionals perform best when expectations are clear.

Our established monthly production standards include:

• $40,000 in new written Property & Casualty premium
• Life-Licensed Producers: Minimum of 4 written life insurance policies per month
• Producers Without a Life License: Minimum of 8 qualified life insurance referrals per month to an appropriately licensed agency representative
• Consistent daily prospecting, quoting, follow-up, and sales activity
• Strong conversion rates, quality business, and professional customer relationships

We're looking for someone who views these goals as achievable standards and is driven to exceed them.

THIS OPPORTUNITY IS FOR YOU IF:

• You have a proven insurance sales track record and want to earn more.
• You enjoy prospecting and closing rather than waiting for the phone to ring.
• You take ownership of your production without needing constant supervision.
• You understand that consistent activity produces consistent results.
• You are motivated by measurable goals, financial achievement, and recognition.
• You want to be part of an ambitious, growing agency.

READY TO PROVE WHAT YOU CAN DO?

We're interested in your track record—not simply the number of years on your résumé.

If you're an experienced, licensed insurance producer with a history of closing business, meeting production goals, and taking ownership of your success, we encourage you to apply.

Tell us about your insurance sales experience, your typical monthly production, and what you've accomplished in previous positions.

Join a recognized, growth-focused agency where performance matters and successful producers have the opportunity to thrive.

*Compensation and bonus eligibility are governed by the agency's compensation plan. Actual earnings depend on performance; the advertised range is not guaranteed.*

Benefits

• Paid Time Off (PTO)
• Flexible Schedule
• Dental Insurance
• Vision Insurance
• Life Insurance
• Disability Insurance
• Hands on Training
• Mon-Fri Schedule
• Evenings Off
• Weekends Off
• Warm Leads Provided
• Career Advancement Opportunities, Including Incentive Trips and Promotions.
• Office Snacks and Refreshments
• Positive, Friendly Work EnvironmentCareer Growth Opportunities
• Career Growth Opportunities

Responsibilities

• Consistently prospect, quote, follow up, and close new insurance business
• Achieve a minimum monthly production goal of $40,000 in new written Property & Casualty premium
• If life licensed, produce a minimum of 4 written life insurance policies per month
• If not life licensed, generate a minimum of 8 qualified life insurance referrals per month for an appropriately licensed agency representative
• Convert agency-provided leads into policies using a consultative, needs-based sales approach
• Present and sell auto, home, commercial, and specialty insurance solutions, as well as life insurance when appropriately licensed
• Identify bundling, cross-selling, and referral opportunities with new and existing customers
• Generate additional business through prospecting, networking, and referral relationships
• Maintain accurate customer records, sales activity, and follow-up tasks in AgencyZoom
• Follow established sales scripts, processes, underwriting guidelines, and compliance standards
• Maintain strong conversion rates and a consistent pipeline of qualified opportunities
• Take ownership of production results and continuously work to improve sales performance

Requirements

• Active Texas Property & Casualty insurance license required
• Minimum 2 years of successful insurance sales experience preferred
• Demonstrated history of meeting or exceeding monthly sales and premium production goals
• Proven ability to prospect, quote, handle objections, and close new business
• Strong communication, relationship-building, and consultative selling skills
• Self-motivated, competitive, goal-oriented, and accountable for individual production
• Ability to maintain consistent outbound sales activity and manage an organized pipeline
• Comfortable working in a structured, performance-driven sales environment
• Commitment to ethical selling practices, underwriting requirements, and regulatory compliance

Preferred Qualifications:

• Active Texas Life Insurance license
• Experience selling personal lines, commercial, and life insurance
• Previous Farmers Insurance or other major carrier experience
• Experience with AgencyZoom or similar insurance CRM platforms
• Demonstrated success generating referrals and self-sourced business
• Bilingual English/Spanish skills are a plus